Pedestrians who regularly cross the busy intersection at Del Paso Boulevard and Arden Way described what they usually see in the area. The intersection was the most heavily ticketed location by Sacramento Police Department officers last year. Nashelly Chavez The Sacramento Bee
Pedestrians who regularly cross the busy intersection at Del Paso Boulevard and Arden Way described what they usually see in the area. The intersection was the most heavily ticketed location by Sacramento Police Department officers last year. Nashelly Chavez The Sacramento Bee

Editorials

What Sacramento’s jaywalking tickets tell us about justice or lack of it

By the Editorial Board

April 17, 2017 05:15 PM

UPDATED April 18, 2017 01:19 PM

A week has passed since a white Sacramento police officer stopped a black 24-year-old on a Del Paso Heights sidewalk, accused him of jaywalking and, when he balked, punched him about 18 times.

Captured on video – by police dash cams and a passerby who posted it on Facebook – the Kafka-esque arrest of Nandi Cain was as baffling as it was brutal. Cain was walking home from work. He was unarmed. There appeared to be no probable cause even to stop him. The footage shows the dreadlocked young man crossing at a corner.

But compared to the last major abuse of Sacramento’s trust in police – the running to ground and shooting last summer of Joseph Mann, a mentally ill man – the response has been a case study in transparent law enforcement.

Lines of communication opened after the Mann shooting channeled fury as the video went viral. The city’s Office of Public Safety Accountability was staffed and reassuring.

Never miss a local story.

Sign up today for a free 30 day free trial of unlimited digital access.

The rank and file may complain, but this city’s cowboy-cop culture has done them no favors.

Mayor Darrell Steinberg, City Manager Howard Chan, Deputy Police Chief Mike Bray and the area police captain, Pamela Seyffert, got out in front of the incident rather than stonewalling. Within 24 hours, a press release detailing the encounter had been issued, community leaders had been briefed, available video had been released, Cain’s charges had been dropped and the officer, a 2015 academy graduate, was on paid administrative leave pending criminal and internal investigations.

Though some in the rank and file sulked at the new accountability like children, this is how it’s supposed to be done.

In fact, if anything, this case has underscored how urgently an attitude adjustment is needed and how critical it is for the next chief to be a reformer. As The Bee’s Anita Chabria, Nashelly Chavez and Phillip Reese reported Saturday, Cain’s jaywalking accusation exemplifies a pattern within the Del Paso Heights police district, which in the past year has been responsible for nearly 75 percent of jaywalking citations issued in the city. Half of those have gone to African-Americans, who are only about 15 percent of the area’s residents.

A slightly higher accident rate notwithstanding, traffic stats don’t paint Del Paso Heights as a pedestrian death trap. So are people being rousted for walking while black? If so, that’s an institutional problem on top of the injurious – and expensive – sensitivity to backtalk.

The rank and file may complain, but this city’s cowboy-cop culture has done them no favors. What will make this job easier, though? Trust.

Police tackle man for jaywalking

A Sacramento officer, attempting to stop a man for jaywalking in the Del Paso Heights neighborhood, was caught on video tackling the man after he refused to obey the officer's commands. This police dashcam video contains language viewers may find offensive.

Sacramento Police Department